Within less than two months it came for minor revision. 18 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation" in English. Click on “View Submission” to view the paper. Awaiting Reviewer Selection The Associate Editor makes a recommendation for the manuscript based upon the reviewers’ comments and his/her own assessment of the work. Awaiting Editor Assignment: Your article has passed initial quality checks by the Editorial Production Assistant and is in the process of being assigned to an appropriate Editor who will evaluate your article for scope, quality, and fit for the journal. Sep 15, 2021 · Soon after the Associate Editor (AE) acknowledges the receipt of the reviewer report, the status is reversed to "Awaiting Referee Report"; probably now the report is pending from other assigned reviewer(s). 11 Awaiting Associate Editor Assignment 6. 小夏_0321 2023-07-18 I have been awaiting AE recommendation for two weeks now. Nov 5, 2019 · The status "Awaiting reviewer assignment" means that your paper has cleared teh initial editorial screening and will be sent for peer review. The GE, as the name suggests, is an external editor and is assigned when the journal cannot find an internal editor to handle the manuscript. The manuscript awaiting the assignment of an editor for more than two-and-half months is both a bit long and unusual. Interestingly, it is/was awaiting "reviewer" (not reviewers- in a plural form) recommendations. ’ Now, it is almost a month since the status changed to ‘Awaiting EIC Decision. 4. Comment. 21 Awaiting Reviewer Scores 7. "真的太急了" translates to "It's really urgent. Aug 3, 2023 · 11. It’s more common to have a challenge finding peer reviewers, unless with this journal or for this paper, the review is to be done internally. 管理者による論文チェック待ち. Papers that do not meet these criteria will be rejected. M. Now the status has changed to ‘Awaiting ED recommendation’. In your particular case, note that "awaiting AE decision" does require some work on the editor's part, or maybe even further discussion from the reviewers. Aug 9, 2022 · I have submitted my paper to one of the springer journal. Feb 28, 2021 · My paper underwent a revision. Thank you for agreeing to serve as an Associate Editor for the IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. 1 Reviews received - awaiting Associate Editor recommendation This means that the reviews have been received and are currently awaiting the recommendation of the Associate Editor. – Feb 9, 2019 · The status ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. However, irrespective of the outcome, the AE's decision should not have been this delayed. I submitted a manuscript to a Sage Journal almost 50 days ago. Now it is almost 3 weeks. After two and half months the status got changed from awaiting reviewer scores to awaiting recommendation. Of course, one cannot be sure, but the status changes seem to indicate a higher possibility of a desk rejection, that is, a rejection without peer review. Nov 19, 2020 · I submitted an article to a ScholarOne journal. 5. A copy of the Admin Checklist will be visible, and editable, once complete. Oct 24, 2020 · This is quite simple. ) A manuscript can have either an ED (AE) assigned or a GE, not both (unless this is for a special issue). Meaning of ‘Awaiting Editor Assignment’ This means that your manuscript has cleared the admin check, that is, it was found matching the journal’s scope and also adhering to the journal’s guidelines, apart from a cursory check of the novelty and quality of the study. By November it showed awaiting EIC decision. Also in most cases, the AE will receive an e-mail to notify him that the minimum number of reviews has been received and he must submit a decision within a couple of days / week. ” Apr 21, 2020 · You have three queries. It seems that the Associate Editor (AE) felt it could fit into a particular section of the journal. The minimum would be either two or three depending on the publication but the associate editor might have sent a few more invitations around. For most manuscripts, in the Geophysical Research Letters (GRL) aims to provide rapid publication of forefront research that has an immediate impact on the science community. "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" means that the paper has been assigned the minimum amount of reviewers that the Associate Editor has set for the manuscript. Even yesterday the status was still "awaiting reviewer selection", but today it was changed to "awaiting EIC decision". Jun 12, 2020 · (For most journals, the associate editor is referred to as the AE. Also, it is not clearly defined what the "with editor" status even means. Sep 10, 2020 · I submitted a paper, and it took 10 days to be assigned editors and reviewers. 29 submitted 5. During this time, the editor looks for suitable reviewers for your paper and sends out review invitations. Admin Checklist. Dec 19, 2017 · I submitted a paper to some journal. Advice for Associate Editors. After that, it took three weeks for ‘Awaiting reviewer scores. 27 Revise and Resubmit Translation: 4. Sep 14, 2020 · What does awaiting editor recommendation mean? The status ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. The editor decides whether your paper fits the aims and scope of the journal, then select the reviewers and guide the paper through several revision stages. t backed up) waiting to be sent to some reviews. Since past 4 days the status is ‘pending editor decision’. This decision should reflect your own opinion of the paper as well as those of the referees. Now in February, 2022, I resumitted the manuscript. The journal says on Mar 28, 2015 · AE stands for "Associate Editor. With Editor: This indicates that an editor has agreed to evaluate the manuscript, and the assignment is in their editorial queue. Maybe a few days. Click on “Take Action. A few days ago, it was changed to "awaiting reviewer selection". Apr 23, 2020 · Because ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means that the manuscript passed the admin and/or Associate Editor (AE) check and was awaiting peer review. Last week, the status changed to Awaiting AE Recommendation. When prompted by an email notification, log in to your editor center and find the manuscript from the dashboard link “Awaiting Reviewer Selection”. It means that the peer review is over, taking about two months, and the peer reviewer recommendations are awaited on the paper. Awaiting Reviewer Selection 投稿SCI杂志，等待AE建议已一个月，是否催稿？知乎上有科研人员分享投稿经验和审稿流程，帮你解答疑惑。 Nov 21, 2016 · In some journals there is a senior editor who oversees different areas; othrers simply have an editor in chief who oversees everything. 2. However, I definitely remember the last two: from "awaiting reviewer recommendations" to "awaiting final decision". ” Scroll down to see the results returned from Referee Locator* or to search for an existing reviewer in the system or to create a new reviewer account. Explore Zhihu's column for a platform that allows users to write and express themselves freely. " Explore a platform for free expression and writing on various topics at Zhihu Zhuanlan. Via the Associate Editor Dashboard, click on the “Awaiting Referee Selection” queue. 19 Under review 6. (Obsessive) googling has led me to answers like that it should take roughly 2-3 days to get an Editor-in-Chief decision. Since they are both now "pending", you could see both status's at the same time. Then I submitted the revised manuscript in 10 days. ” 5. This allows the editor/admin to make a decision without sending the manuscript to review. Based on the reviewers’ comments, on the Associate Editor recommendation, and on her/his own reading of the paper, the Editor sends a decision letter to the authors. ""Awaiting AE recommendation" status means that the AE has collected all reviews from the reviewers who were assigned to review your manuscript and that the AE's decision for acceptance is pending. So, the reviewers will share their comments with the Associate Editor (AE) along with their recommendations for the paper – whether (or not) they believe the paper has merit and should therefore be considered (or not) for publication. 20 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment 6. So That’s It? That’s it. May 25, 2020 · To get right into it, your (seniors’) understanding of the ‘Awaiting EiC Decision’ in ScholarOne's Manuscript Central (called ‘Decision in Process’ in some other systems) is correct to some extent. , to the Editor in Chief/Editorial Board. So, yes, it is always good to write an email after three or four months of unchanged online status, but it won't help very much. For the first week of submission, the status was "with editor" and then it changed to under review for one week, then reviewers asigned Feb 15, 2023 · Tour Start here for a quick overview of the site Help Center Detailed answers to any questions you might have Aug 30, 2020 · Answer: The status ‘Awaiting Referee Selection’ typically means that the manuscript is awaiting peer review. Associate Editor の指名待ち Awaiting AE Recommendation. Nov 2, 2020 · Status stuck at Awaiting Editor Assignment. The status of the paper on the journal management system is still ‘submitted to the journal. May I know is there any chances for at least to get a major revision. Feb 9, 2020 · ‘Awaiting Editorial Office Processing’ means that the manuscript was awaiting an Editorial Office (EO) or Associate Editor (AE) check for aspects such as adherence to guidelines, match with the journal’s scope, and novelty of the study. I don't think it took long for them to get back to me last time when it changed to awaiting recommendation. 17 Awaiting Editor Assignment - This means that as of April 17th, the person or document is waiting for an editor to be assigned. Click into that category, then click into the manuscript. In the month of December, I got a "reject and resubmit" decision. The journal features articles from a broad range of disciplines, and our reviewers help in evaluating both the scientific content (Categories 1-4) and the presentation quality (Categories A-C) to determine whether a submitted manuscript meets GRL Jun 7, 2020 · What does mean awaiting AE recommendation? The status ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. What does this mean? Was the manuscript reviewed? I think the status should have changed to something like Awaiting Reviewer Scores before Awaiting EIC Decision. ’ It is a little odd that the latter statuses are taking longer. Eic usually signifies the Editor in chief. ’ How much more time should I wait for a response? Aug 26, 2022 · Awaiting associate editor recommendation --> referee reports are completed, and the journal has some associate editor(s) decide on the basis of the reports (and their own reading of the paper?) whether to recommend acceptance, rejection, etc. Once initial check up is done on your manuscript, the EIC will screen your manuscript to check if it fits the scope of the journal and if it is of sufficient interest to the journal's readership. When all the reviews are completed, you can make your preliminary recommendation that will be sent to the EiC for approval. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. At first, the status showed "awaiting AE recommendation". 21 Awaiting AE Recommendation 7. Awaiting Reviewer Selection, which is the next stage, means that the editor has received responses from multiple peer reviewers and is presently in the process of making a selection among them. Still the status is same. Jul 24, 2023 · 7. NOTE: Before Nov 6, 2023 · 6 November 2023. So, why has it returned to the referee(s) after last week's status? Aug 14, 2022 · My manuscript has been peer reviewed over 8 weeks, flicked through "Awaiting AE Decision" in a day but then seems to have gotten stuck, as it has been at "Awaiting EIC Decision" for over a week. Later, it has been under "Awaiting review scores" for the past 25 days. 18 Awaiting AE Recommendation translates to "7. hello, I am expereincing a delay. During reject and resubmit, I got comments from 2 reviewers, and Editor Invited: It means the manuscript has been assigned to an editor and is waiting for the editor to agree to evaluate the manuscript. Via the Associate Editor Dashboard, click on the “Awaiting Reviewer Selection” queue. Awaiting AE Assignment. Jul 30, 2021 · 3. This is not an unusual process and is encountered with Awaiting recommendation' implies that the peer review of your paper is complete and the Associate Editor or Editor-in-Chief will check the reviews and give his/her recommendation on acceptance May 4, 2023 · How long should I wait before contacting the journal editor to ask about the status of my submitted paper? I've been waiting for a couple of weeks without hearing anything. Also, ‘SAE’ perhaps stands for ‘Specialist Associate Editor. Read 39 answers by scientists with 2 recommendations from their colleagues to the question asked by Fernando Lima on Aug 11, 2017 But similar conditions in long days contact the editor and ask We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Answer: The change in status from 'Under review' to 'Pending recommendation' implies that the peer review of your paper is complete and the Associate Editor or Editor-in-Chief will check the reviews and give his/her recommendation on acceptance, rejection, or further revision. One of them got accepted within 10 days, but the status for the other one has been "Awaiting AE assignment" for 15 days now. AE assigns reviewers: The Associate Editor has started selecting and inviting reviewers, but the number of agreed-reviewers has not reached 4, the TMI recommended number. But how does the editor actually take the decision on a manuscript? This article explains the sequence of events that lead from peer review to editorial decision making: how the AE procures the completed reviews, assesses them, and finally comes to a decision on whether to accept the manuscript, request Authors will be asked to respond to the comments and recommendations of the reviewers within 15 days, or longer if deemed necessary by the Associate Editor or at the discretion of the Associate Editor at the request of the corresponding author. Forward to Admin/Editor and Admin/Editor List Authors will be asked to respond to the comments and recommendations of the reviewers within 15 days, or longer if deemed necessary by the Associate Editor or at the discretion of the Associate Editor at the request of the corresponding author. If ‘Awaiting EIC Decision’ is taking too long, is that a good sign or a bad sign? Any thoughts? Feb 17, 2021 · As an editor myself, I can tell you that journal submission systems often send reminder emails to editors automatically. Nov 21, 2016 · But if your paper has not gone through peer review, and the status has changed directly from “With editor” to “Awaiting AE decision,” it could mean that your paper has been desk rejected. 21 Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation 7. 去年11月，我在老师的建议下投了一篇TMECH的文章，中间经过漫长的审稿、拒稿/大修，改稿、润色，最后到今天把大修的论文 Feb 17, 2021 · For the first 10 days, it was reviewed by the managing editor and sent to us for some format issues, etc. ’” Don’t wait! Communicate! Mar 15, 2016 · Once a paper is submitted to a journal, authors eagerly wait for the editorial decision. This is possible! For instance, let's say the journal assigned 3 reviewers, but only requires 2 to move on to the recommendation task. The Editor-in-Chief and Associate Editor should also adhere to timely review as indicated in Table 1. PaperPlaza codes for the common recommendation types are AR for Accept as Regular; CR for Conditionally Accept as Regular; RR for Revise and Resubmit as Regular; R for Reject; and RE for Editorial Reject. It has been over two weeks, but the status is still displayed as ‘Awaiting Admin Processing. However, today, it changed back to Awaiting Referee Scores. Oct 24, 2020 · A direct change after submission (or after the initial admin check) to ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ typically means that the Associate Editor (AE) has had a look at the paper and decided not to send it for review. While selection as Associate Editor may be seen as a recognition of the high esteem in which you are held by your peers, please note that the position is not merely honorary—there is a lot of work to be done! (3) The Associate Editor checks that the research is scientifically rigorous and that the manuscript is of interest to the specific subject area. The Editor and AEs should also adhere to timely review as indicated in Table 1. However, i can see on the portal the duration for submission to first decision is shown as 28 days. Read 214 answers by scientists with 2 recommendations from their colleagues to the question asked by Ahmed S. Note that as long as there are less than 4 agreed reviewers, this status will remain unchanged even though the Associate Editor has been actively recruiting new reviewers. Click the blue “Take Action” checkmark. Sep 14, 2019 · “Awaiting SE Recommendation” means that it went to a Section Editor (SE) of the journal for checking the match with that section of the journal. But my question is as below Jan 8, 2021 · I submitted a minor revision for my paper based on the comments by the editor and Reviewers 1 and 2. I am not 4. Saleh on May 3, 2018 How long one should wait on an editor's decision depends We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. After careful scrutiny, the Associate Editor selects and prioritises six reviewers and the first two are invited to review. You will see a category for papers awaiting the AE recommendation. Some editors keep a paper for long time, more than 6 months or a year, without a decision and when send them a reminder message they do not reply or sometimes reply for the first time saying that Also known as with editors (APS), review completed, required reviews completed (Elsevier Editorial System (EES)), awaiting AE recommendation, awaiting decision (ScholarOne), awaiting EiC decision (IEEE), Editor Decision Started (AIP), Decision Started (NPG), or pending decision (Bioinformatics Oxford journal). According to the process described in IEEE Transactions, "Awaiting AE recommendation" status means that the AE has collected all reviews from the reviewers who were assigned to review your manuscript and that the AE's decision for acceptance is pending. Jan 13, 2022 · The EiC, Editor and Associate Editor ensure that there is no conflict of interest in the review process, and that papers are treated in a respectful, impartial and ethical manner. I am not entirely clear about the wording of the latest status. Mar 16, 2022 · I submitted manuscript in October, 2021. The status of the paper changed several times. Feb 26, 2021 · Awaiting Reviewer Assignment means the journal editor has started reaching out to potential reviewers for your manuscript. 3. Well this is just one scenario. If so, it seems to have gone from this decision to awaiting a decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EiC). The AE then conveys their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who makes the final decision. If a manuscript has received reviews, please use the standard “Make Decision” task to make a decision. And from the past few days, I see it as "Awaiting AE recommendation". Awaiting Admin Checklist. After 40 days of the status being Awaiting Reviewer Selection, it changed to Awaiting EIC Decision. As per my understanding, the status should be Awaiting EIC Decision. Now for the last 2 weeks, it's showing awaiting EIC. It then moved to ‘Awaiting reviewer selection’ and stayed at that stage for 9 days. Mar 9, 2022 · Answer: Dear author, The editorial hierarchy varies from journal to journal. Checking the Reviews Thomus please ignore my recent response. 博四了，真的太急了 - "博四了" is not clear and could have multiple interpretations. Jul 1, 2017 · Read 23 answers by scientists with 2 recommendations from their colleagues to the question asked by Habibullah Khan on Jul 1, 2017 Nov 21, 2022 · Read 4 answers by scientists with 1 recommendation from their colleagues to the question asked by Sanyam Sharma on Nov 21, 2022 Feb 12, 2014 · Since about three years, average review times increased from 3-4 months to 5-7 months, at least in the non-top 4 journals. This may not apply. Perhaps the editor has invited multiple reviewers, but is waiting for enough reviewers to accept the paper review. Let’s take them one by one. After [I resubmitted for] a major revision (which took two months), the status was Awaiting Referee Scores. Paper sent to Editor-in-Chief (EIC) for screening and assigning to Associate Editors (AE); Internal review of the quality and suitability of the paper, the manuscript may be rejected without external review if the paper does not fit the scope of J-BHI or the quality of the paper does not meet the minimal standards as required by the Journal. Jul 24, 2018 · However, in your case, since the paper was not assigned to an Associate Editor, I feel inclined to think that the "Under Review" status refers to the initial editorial review, not peer review. The Editor-in-Chief (EiC) makes the final decision on manuscript, with the associate editor (AE) making the initial decision. That was actually referring to my SECOND paper (which I am still awaiting the outcome for). I know the next stage is to Editor In chief. I have submitted two articles to a journal. Aug 9, 2023 · 6. 1 Accept as Regular (AR) and Accept as Oct 8, 2015 · AE stands for Associate Editor. This means the initial check on the manuscript is complete, which means that the Editor-in-Chief (EiC) and/or the Associate Editor (AE) believe/s the manuscript fulfills basic journal criteria such as novelty of the research, quality of the writing, match with the journal’s scope Mar 5, 2017 · The system in most Transactions lets you change the minimum number of reviews so that the status is "Under Review" rather than "with Associate Editor". . The Senior Editor makes a final decision based upon the Associate Editor’s recommendation, the reviewers’ comments, and his/her assessment of the manuscript. How long I should wait for the final verdict? Mar 24, 2016 · 尊敬的 Eddy 博士： 我初次投稿后，编辑部拒稿了，但给了根据审稿意见修改后重投的建议。我的修改稿重投后，很快进入 under review 状态；1 个月后变成 Awaiting AE Recommendation，至目前，此状态已持续了 3 周，我大概还要等多长时间，才能看到审稿结论？ 谢谢！ Feb 12, 2014 · Since about three years, average review times increased from 3-4 months to 5-7 months, at least in the non-top 4 journals. I have previously published in the same journal and it had taken 5 months to Aug 3, 2021 · Dear Team, First, thank you for running such a stunning forum. Aug 4, 2018 · Three weeks ago, I submitted my paper to a social sciences journal with impact factor. Scroll down to see the results returned from Referee Locator* or to search for an existing reviewer in the system or to create a new reviewer account. In addition to the summary report, the AE makes a publication recommendation to the Editor. Depending on the journal contact one of these to check the status of your paper. For 2 weeks, the submission status was showing ‘Awaiting admin processing’. Assuming your paper's undergone peer review, it could mean that the paper is back from the peer reviewer/s, and after the Associate/Managing Editor (AE/ME) has had a look, they have arrived at a decision and referred their decision to the PE/EIC, who will make the final decision. The Associate Editor then makes a recommendation to the Editor to reject the manuscript, selects appropriate reviewers, or occasionally will ask the author to make revisions before sending it for review. We request that authors suggest reviewers in their cover letters, but we also leave it at the Editor’s discretion to select appropriate reviewers. little_foo 2021-10-18 To get to the AE recommendation tab, go to your Associate Editor dashboard by clicking “Associate Editor Center” in the top gray bar or from under the “Manage” dropdown in the top gray bar. Mar 4, 2021 · What you are seeing generally indicates that there is at least 1 review task pending, and also a recommendation task pending. 24 Awaiting EIC Decision 7. ’ Reviewers who take months or years to submit their review (it sits on their backlog until the editor pesters them enough to complete it). Under “Editor Actions,” click on “Awaiting AE Recommendation,” and then “Take Action” and “Make Recommendation. A platform for free expression and writing at will. So I thought it passed the associate editor's evaluation and now they were looking for reviewers. now, it is over 32 days but we have not received the first decision neither an acceptance or rejection. If that was the case for your paper, then a subsequent change to "Awaiting reviewer invitation" would mean that the editor is sending your paper for an additional review. Jun 27, 2018 · Generally, the status changes to "Awaiting ED recommendations" once peer review for the paper is done and the reviewer comments have come in. Dec 2, 2021 · "Awaiting PE decision" could mean one of two things. 24 Awaiting Editor-in-Chief Decision Once manuscripts are uploaded, they are all seen by the Editor after submission on a daily basis and, providing they seem suitable, are allocated to the appropriate Associate Editor. Feb 18, 2022 · Once through this stage, your manuscript will move on to a stage such as “Awaiting Recommendation” and/or “Awaiting Decision” and it generally won’t be long before a decision is sent to you. rf ty fc pu hb wp ld nf bv kd