The status is "pending editor triage" since one month from the initial submission! Finally, the editor in Chief finalizes the decision. Please, there is an opportunity to include all the recommendations by the reviewers to improve the manuscript. After manuscript submission, an initial quality check on the manuscript is performed by the Publisher to ensure that the paper is formatted correctly. Also known as with editors (APS), review completed, required reviews completed ( Elsevier Editorial System (EES) ), awaiting AE recommendation , awaiting decision (ScholarOne), awaiting EiC decision (IEEE), Editor Decision Started (AIP), Decision May 26, 2022 · 举人. The Editor has made a decision and requested you revise the submission. 불길한 징조일까요? 걱정이 되서 깊은 잠을 못 자고 있습니다. Feb 21, 2021 · 本贴吧是一个关于MDPI出版社的投稿经验分享平台，用户可以在这里讨论MDPI的审稿速度、质量、费用等问题。本页面展示了一些用户对MDPI的pending editor decision状态的疑问和回答，以及一些投稿成功的案例。 5 days ago · applied sciences大修修回Pending editor decision. 22都在Sustainability投了文章，一个5. pending ed. 标签： 修修 意见 审稿 日大 性大 专家 投稿 二审 一审 大神. 二审一个审稿人同意接收，另外一个有一个小建议，编辑给的小修当天修改完提交，小修提交之后第二天先变rvr两个小时后变成ped。. 请问各位大佬，为啥二审我只能看到第三个审稿人的意见，其他审稿人的意见都看不到。. 14 Pending English 2023. Editorial Process. 是明确有reject的表达吗？. The world of publishing is one of those examples. Apr 29, 2024 · 小修pending editor decision还有会拒稿？. Jun 19, 2023 · applied sciences. This can take another few days or We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 然后都给了五六条意见。. Apr 4, 2023 · 3. 01 5974- 1 일주일내로 답변이 오더군요. Most journals have their own criteria for selecting an editor for a particular paper and the delay could be due to editor unavailability. Reject:The paper has been through the peer review process and Jun 23, 2021 · 经历了一次大修后进入pending editor decsion 然后学术编辑决定accept after minor revision。. 举人. Earlier it was pending recommendation. 35天返回的一审意见一见是小修，三个审稿人都很正面. 还有就是第一轮大修三个审稿人意见修改后第二轮 3 days ago · 状态Pending editor decision. Sometimes, this can take anywhere between 2-6 weeks. 16 Author After peer review, the editor will consider feedback from the reviewers and then make a decision about the article. #稿件处理咨询#. Decisions letters are proofread in the order in which the manuscript was submitted. 一审结束后，两个都说语言有很大问题，长句子有的看不懂啥的，然后一个开头说了祝贺辛苦的工作，一个说了我读了一篇很有意思的文章。. 1. Decision notification e-mails and what they mean. No matter which decision you receive, be sure to read the entire decision letter carefully. Pending editor decision이 stats에 떴습니다. Because the world of publishing can be quite scary, we’ve gone through Mar 18, 2024 · 1. Aug 23, 2018 · Aug 22, 2018 at 20:48. 因为Pending decision出现 Editorial decision and Revision. @Adam, based on what OP has described, I would not recommend sending a reminder before one month from "Decision pending". 谢谢各位大佬解答！. 那么现在是要等编辑给我decision的结果后，再做下一步打算吗？. 13 Pending editor decision （意见全部提升，三位审稿人回信，两位建议直接发表，一审大修那位感谢我们的修改） 2023. Based on the reviewers’ comments the editor takes the final decision. Nov 24, 2017 · Comment. For all subsequent steps, please check Next steps for publishing your article: What to expect after acceptance. 塔普哒. Oct 3, 2022 · 学术编辑决定就行了，基本都会通过的，提前恭喜了。. 一是，同时投稿会影响接收吗？. Page 3 of 7. Explore thought-provoking articles and insights on Zhihu's column platform. 本文为你详细解读SCI论文投稿后的不同状态，包括 reviewer invited 、under review、ready for decision等，帮你了解审稿进度和结果。 Mar 15, 2016 · Once a paper is submitted to a journal, authors eagerly wait for the editorial decision. 15号投稿. 01 5384 - 2 재 제출했습니다. 大家好我来更新一下后续啦！今天下午刚好结束答辩，和导师交流了一下回来就发现状态变成了pending editor decision了两个审稿人全都给了yes，还有一个还没给答复，但是已经很开心了 Aug 31, 2022 · freemyandi. 第三个审稿人第一次就对文章进行了全盘否定+6个must就给出两条修改意见：补充文章研究动机和使用方法的依据，并 Note that the editor might not always wait for all reviews to be returned before making a decision. In my field, I don't send any reminders until at We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. All the best for the next update! Jul 13, 2023 · 라운드 2까지 끝내고 pending editor decision 단계에서 academic editor 에게. Click the action View Reviews and Comments to see all completed reviews and editor decisions. Nov 17, 2017 · 2. 修改后现在反回3个意见，还差1个，3个都是全yes明确表示可以出版。. 或者“拒稿”？. 审稿人：大家都懂 3. They may sometimes ask you to submit to a sister (related) journal instead (in case it’s a big publisher with multiple journals). 5月26号返回，Revised Version Review. 楼主 你的pending editor decision状态刚开始时就有两个审稿人的二审意见吗，还是在这个状态下会有其他人的意见持续返回？. 我有两个问题想问一下群里的小伙伴们。. Oct 19, 2022 · Pending decision一周了. The decision letter is delivered to the author via email. Explore a collection of articles and insights on various topics in the Zhihu column. 评论里审稿人A 明确给minor revision The handling editor considers all the returned reviews before making a decision. Now it's the editor's turn to come to a final decision. 期间重新提交也没收到助理编辑的邮件，只有最开始投稿的时候收到了助理编辑的邮件…后面都是Managing Editor发 Nov 6, 2023 · Learn about the review process of MDPI journals, including how to recommend reviewers, access review reports, and deal with rejections. 我也想知道，一审两个审稿人，大修返回后只能看到 Aug 12, 2020 · The AE typically checks for factors such as the novelty of the research and the quality of the paper, to decide whether or not to send it for peer review. 经常看到吧里有人状态是Pending Decision，就开始紧张，其实根据个人多次投稿经历，这是个正常必经流程。. The Decision is Communicated. 卜留痕迹. The editor sends a decision email to the author including any relevant reviewer comments. 返回修改后，Round 2 两个审稿人接收了，另一个审稿人还有一些意见：一是让把给他的回复中的实验加到正文里，二是加一个方法的文字对比表（这部分在round 1中我加 Dec 13, 2022 · 第二次大修，二审pending major revision. 看完就大概知道自己能是个什么结果。. 但是状态是pending decision而不是pending editor decision，这是为什么呢没有消极意见啊也。. Eventually, an editor will make a decision and you will get your paper back with comments from peer reviewers. 23晚上变成Pending editor decision。. It is likely that the change "under review" -> "decision pending" means that referee (s) report (s) were received, and now the editor has to make the decision. 15 English correction done 2023. 明明一审的时候第二个审稿人的意见最多，二审他 Feb 18, 2023 · 2023. Resubmission pending. 05 Pending Review 2023. Once a paper is submitted to a journal, it goes through an initial screening process. This status simply means that your paper is yet to be assigned to an editor. Click the action Notify Editor to send an email to the current handling editor (last assigned editor who has not made a decision). There will be some time between a manuscript entering the “Decision pending” queue and the contact author receiving the decision letter. Fingers crossed 🤞, we got an email from them stating "We thank you for your submission and acknowledge the delay in responding with a decision. I am experiencing the same thing. ‘Under editorial consideration’ and ‘Decision pending’ simultaneously: The AE must have had a look at the paper and made a decision on it, and communicated this decision to the Editor Sep 29, 2014 · 5 mins. 是openaccess吗？. Answer: Thank you for your question. Pending editor decision이 떠서 당황스럽습니다. Being an early career researcher is tough. 这两天编辑就会给意见。. Based on this information, the EiC may also modify their decision. Mar 14, 2024 · Scroll down to and look for the journal metrics displayed after the Aims and Scope. 02. It may be that the journal might be waiting to decide based on the theme of the upcoming issue. 修回去，现在又变成pending editor decision（已经两天了） 这种会等多久啊. 可以看到大修审稿人二审 When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. MDPI旗下的期刊，2月9日投稿，2月28号收到大修，3个审稿人，3月14号截止日期改完回去，3月22号能看到3个审稿人的und 2 review report，第一个审稿人给了5个can be impved，但给的意见是语言需要改进，第二个审稿人给了5个yes Sep 17, 2019 · You will see little messages like ‘awaiting editorial approval’, ‘awaiting reviewer scores’, ‘awaiting editorial board comments’ and ‘decision pending’ as your article wends its way through this process. If the metrics do not appear, then the journal is not yet Sep 18, 2020 · Learn what 'Pending Decision' means in the context of journal submission and peer review. Revised manuscript received by the Dove Editorial offices. Mar 13, 2024 · When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. 2. This is a provisional acceptance, pending final checks for formatting and technical requirements. Revision: The Editor has made a decision and requested the author revise the submission. 我的一轮3个审稿人，二轮刚返回来一个审稿人意见就显示pending editor decision. Apr 9, 2024 · If you are not the handling editor, you can check up on the submission. 我是大修，revised version review10天，pending editor decision只用了半天。. When the decision is finalized the corresponding author will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. 30和4. 一审四个审稿人，大修. My first PhD research paper is under the status "pending decision". 저는 introduction과 discussion을 대폭 수정하였기에 second round에 들어갈 것으로 예상했었는데. In your case, it seems that the manuscript has cleared the editorial assessment and has already undergone a peer review. this screening is done by the editor. 4141 원글 MDPI Pending editor decision 기간 질문 옵션 21. 我是第二次投mdpi了 第一次被编辑拒绝并鼓励重投了，然后加东西修改完提交上去了 有四个审稿人 3同意 一拒绝 而且态度很 Sep 3, 2023 · Hello Dear Katherine Bosworth, I submitted my research paper in the Axioms Journal with manuscript ID: axioms-2242258 on 09-02-2023 and revised version on 29-03-2023. 一次大修，一次小修，然后pending editor decision之后又变成了revised version review，请问大家这是什么情况呢？发现现在状态又变成pending editor decision今天终于accept了 Explore the world of creative writing and self-expression on Zhihu's dedicated platform for sharing ideas and insights. Aug 22, 2018 · Once a manuscript is submitted to a journal, the journal editor carries out a preliminary assessment before sending it to external peer reviewers. 兄弟们，我的论文第二轮大修提交上去过后没有返回审稿人意见让我做第三轮修改，先是rvr了一周的样子，然后直接变成Pending editor decision了，这种情况是不是要寄了啊。. 一审三个审稿人 一个审稿人直接同意接收，一个审稿人提了格式问题，小修，一个审稿人提了五个问题，建议大修。. May 12, 2022 · 我的pending editor decision也5. See the screenshot for an example. But how does the editor actually take the decision on a manuscript? This article explains the sequence of events that lead from peer review to editorial decision making: how the AE procures the completed reviews, assesses them, and finally comes to a decision on whether to accept the manuscript, request Jun 4, 2024 · 白丁. In many journals the decision does not fall solely on the editor Sep 12, 2021 · Recently, I learnt that the submission can also be done through the Taylor & Francis website, and there when the paper returns from review it shows decision pending (waiting for editorial decision), while in the Scholar One system it shows under review. 等吧，编剧过两天会给大修意见，然后你才可以在网页上提交修改说明和修改稿件。. 此文是在mdpi投的第二篇。. 黄远鹏 1661 次浏览 866 赞 2024-07-15 15:56. To update you, two reviews have been returned. Return without review: If the editor finds that the paper does not match We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 4bc. 第一次投英文的小白不懂，当时一下子投过去两篇，就是想着保保底 Jun 7, 2022 · Pending Decision该怎么处理呢？. 大修的可能性最大，就算有审稿人给的是拒稿，但是学术编辑也会综合其他审稿人的意见，以及以及对这篇文章的理解来觉得，审稿人不一定是小同行，提出 Oct 7, 2021 · Answer: Thank you for your question. 想问一下这种情况接收的几率大吗？. . Answer: When the status for a manuscript changes "Under Review" to "Ready for Decision", it means that the peer-review process is complete and only the editorial decision is pending. sunshineNO1 1752 次浏览 770 赞 2024-07-15 14:49. 30号 出现editor decision，说建议文章在开头和结尾处添加一些和topic相联系的内容； 2. 21上午变成Pending editor decision，一个5. We cannot determine what the EiC has decided by this message alone. pending The decision letter draft is submitted for proofreading by the journal’s editorial staff. 还有就是一般大家的ped都持续多久啊，马上五一了 Apr 7, 2024 · 二轮大修过后Pending editor decision一周了. leyou211 5065 次浏览 Nov 4, 2022 · pending decision代表坏结果吗. 送TA礼物 Aug 31, 2022 · 一审直接进入“pending decision”， 该如何操作啊。. Feb 28, 2024 · 1. 然后我提交了修改稿之后，当天晚上，这个建议大修的 A Zhihu column that allows for free expression and writing at will. In Elsevier, particularly, Jan 29, 2018 · Answer: A status change directly from "With editor" to "Decision in process" usually implies a desk rejection. 07. Reply Jan 3, 2023 · 1 Answer to this question. 来自 Android客户端 9楼 2023-02-11 19:19. 这个学术编辑第一轮外审的时候处理稿件的速度就很快，从审稿意见回来到大修决定 可以在中看到审稿人的comments了。. 11重新提交. MDPI journals operate a single-blind or double-blind peer review process with at least two independent reviewers and an academic editor. Pending decision一半概率是拒稿重投一半概率是大修。. 5. I encourage the authors to carefully do that and submit for review A platform for free expression and writing at will. 16号 pending decision； 一直到现在还是pending decision， 可以看见三个审稿人意见，有一个审稿人很消极。 发邮件给助理编辑说是在等学术编辑的意见，已经很多天了，什么时候才变 Nov 20, 2023 · Stage 4: Decision. The Editor-in-Chief or another editor makes the final acceptance or rejection decision based on the review reports and the author's response. 8返回小修. 有没有懂得兄弟，一轮4个审稿人，意见都还可以。. 6. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 投稿MDPI下的applied sciences，4月16日大修修回，当天显示revised version review，4月20日显示Pending editor decision，而且看见一个审稿专家意见为修改满意，另一个专家一审 Feb 10, 2023 · 过了pending decision后，会给你发邮件告诉你大修还是小修的，系统状态也会更新，一般2天内会做出决定。. 同 pending editor decision，一样焦灼中. 小沙粒的绚烂. Feb 5, 2022 · The status of the paper has since changed from "Under Review" to "Decision Pending", and recently, maybe 4 days ago, the status has changed to "Decision Pending Approval". 耐心等，已经稳了，好消息 Apr 14, 2024 · 这一点网上确实有人提到，同时结合我小修之后进入Pending editor decision的速度来看，似乎这一次确实是这样。 多位审稿人的意见如果 不集中 ，那么修改后手稿的接收概率或许就大一些。 May 12, 2022 · 想问问大家revis. 3. Round 1 三个审稿人，一个同意接收，两个大修。. Jul 27, 2023 · 白丁. 投稿Remote sensing. You may see the action Submit Editor Decision and 4a. Click the 'Review Time' link to see to see the average number of weeks it takes for a manuscript to reach first and final decision over the last several years. The article is unlikely to be accepted on the first round, and it's best for OP not to give the editor an early sense that they are impatient authors. 14 Paper accepted (最佳情人节礼物) 2023. 二审中两个审稿人对于修改十分满意，全部yes，并同意发表。. 当天变成pending editor decision. 7. 一般需要多长时间呀？. If the reviews differ widely, the editor may invite an additional reviewer so as to get an extra opinion before making a decision. However, the final decision may not be only that of an acceptance or a rejection. There are three basic types of decisions: Accept, Revise, and Reject. 27状态变成pending editor decision. 请问下楼主。. There are several decisions that authors may receive after submitting their paper to one of the Society’s journals: Reject without review:The Action Editor has rejected the paper without sending it for peer review. The Editor-in-Chief, the Deputy Editor and the Guest Editor (s) of a Special Issue are then notified of the submission and invited to perform a Pending decision after peer review. Mar 26, 2020 · Coming to your query, Decision in Process typically means that the associate editor (AE) has gone through the peer review comments, arrived at a decision on the manuscript based on the comments, and then conveyed their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC). Since 10-04-2023 the status of our research paper is “Pending Editor Decision”. This status will remain until you begin the process of submitting your revision. Since you (nor I) know how your paper's status is changed in the journal's website, you shouldn't jump to conclusions. 9. 현재 mdpi저널 중 한 곳에서 publication 을 진행중입니다. Sep 3, 2021 · Rejections after peer review can come from a variety of reasons. There’s a vast world out there to explore, and that’s exciting. The editor will then decide whether to accept your work as is, request minor or major revisions, or reject the paper due to unresolvable concerns. 보다 구체적으로는 special issue에 초대되어 원래는 12월 중순까지 원고를 넘겼어야 했지만 시간이 더 걸려 1월 17일 제출-> 2월 17일에 저널측으로부터 minor revision (같은 . If the paper clears the initial screening, it is sent for peer review; else, it is rejected. 贡士. Revise. Feb 25, 2022 · Mdpi저널이 확실히 빠른 거 같긴 하네요. PLOS ONE uses two levels of accept decision. 12 Pending editor decision, 系统里可以看到审稿人的意见，这时只剩一个审稿人的意见了，他的意见是修改稿很好解答了他的问题，谢谢。应该是编辑觉得另一个审稿人应该没意见，没让他给第二轮意见了。然后就是漫长的等待，中间催了两次助理编辑 Aug 3, 2021 · If that is the case with this journal, the status change to "Pending Approval" means that a decision about your manuscript has been reached and this decision is pending approval from the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who will take the final call on the paper. 助理编辑：说难听点就是打打下手，发发通知的。. Feb 12, 2021 · For insights into peer review and journal decision-making that may help address any remaining worries, you may wish to go through the following articles: Peer review process and editorial decision making at journals; How a journal editor reaches a decision on a manuscript after peer review; Hope that helps. If the status does not change, you could write to the journal editor and enquire about the Nov 27, 2023 · 一审大修之后pending editor decision 好焦虑. 编辑信会晚个几天到达。. 想请教各位大佬，大修返稿之后变成了pending editor decision，然后有一个审稿人意见已经回来了，是accepted，这样是等待学术编辑决定接收还是拒绝吗？. Completed - Accept/Reject We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Could you please tell me still how much will it take in final decision? Thanks. The decision may need to be confirmed by multiple Editors in some cases. 标签： 审稿 二审 大修 满意 答复 意见 建议 投稿 修改 量化. 谢谢！. 投了一篇 Nov 8, 2022 · pending editor decision：这是我最焦虑的地方，我以为这不是什么好事！因为这个状态持续了8天。我之前没有投过这个期刊！ accept：11月8日！ 我是10月12日投稿，到录用基本是一个月吧 有啥问题也可以为各位解答一下（前提是我知道的），祝各位好运吧！ In my experience, " decision pending " means that the editor has already received the reviewers' reports. 再等这么久评不上奖学金了. jyyoon 21. 05 Revised version review 2023. 我投稿时是这样子. 26晚修好返回. The status, "Awaiting ED decision" most likely indicates that the manuscript is with the journal editor (likely editor-in-chief) for final checks before you receive the verdict. 5月31号变成了 Pending editor decision 一直到现在. While this status (the EiC’s decision) is indicated by ‘Decision in Process’ by most Oct 27, 2021 · Pending review= 論文が査読前チェックの状態; Under review= 論文の査読が行われている状態; Pending decision= Academic Editorが最初の評価を行っている状態(通常、48時間程度かかります) Pending major or minor revisions= 著者による修正が行われている状態 Dec 4, 2022 · Early Career Researcher Guide. Find answers to common questions and contact the editorial office for more information. Among those that may warrant a rebuttal are: an outlier review, reviewer assumptions and perspectives that lead to an inaccurate or unfair review, reviewers and editors misunderstanding the data and conclusions, and a perceived lack of conceptual advance. See an answer from Editage Insights with an example and a link to a handbook of templates. 到现在状态也没变过. Nov 22, 2023 · pending ed. 我一个 舍友 投的文章，三个审稿人，都没给Not applicable, 只有两个yes 和两个must，其他的10来个都是can improve. My understanding is that the editor has made the decision based on the reviews, but they have now passed the decision to the editor-in-chief. 芭比q了，我的情况和你差不多，我现在是pending editor decision 十五天了还没消息，你这二十一天后被拒绝，太绝望了。. 第一次pending editor decision将进两周. Once a manuscript is submitted to a journal, it goes through an initial screening process which involves a preliminary review by the journal editor or the editorial board. 学术编辑：给文章把关的，是否 May 23, 2023 · 第一轮修好返回去后审稿人觉得可以就直接pending editor decision，不行的话就会再给继续修；第二轮修好返回去后审稿人觉得可以也直接pending editor decision，不行的话助理编辑会发邮件询问你还可以针对意见继续改不，不能的话就请学编做最后裁决，能的话会给你继续修；第三轮修完无论好坏直接pending Sep 28, 2022 · 这一次就比较纠结了，主要是在两个地方，一个是pending editor decision，还有一个是pending decision, 耗费的时间特别久。 在这个投稿过程之中，还有一个有意思的事情，刚开始直接被拒绝了我就表示很怀疑他们的初审工作。 Jul 2, 2022 · 7、Pending editor decision 5-14 9:30（都是第一轮的意见，审稿人2联系不上了！但是学编一直非要他的意见，只能一直僵持着）8、Pending editor decision 5-29 16:55（英语需要适当修改，其他没问题，不过后面接受也没受影响）9、Paper accepted 6-3 8:30 （对于等待他们僵持很多天后一个不错的慰藉）历经两个多月的 Feb 7, 2020 · 1 Answer to this question. 二轮小修resubmitted后几个小时之内变成pending decision了，有人知道为啥吗？. Dove Editorial has communicated the Editor-in-Chief's decision to the author (s) and Dove is awaiting a revised and/or resubmitted manuscript. 一个全yes，但提到摘要结论都需要改；一个两must 一can三 Oct 27, 2023 · 此外，“pending editor decision”并不一定意味着文章已经被接受。 它只是表示学术编辑正在考虑是否接收该论文。 有时候，这个过程会比较长，因为编辑可能需要时间来评估论文的质量、创新性以及与期刊的符合度等各个方面。 May 25, 2020 · The Editor-in-Chief (EiC) makes the final decision on manuscript, with the associate editor (AE) making the initial decision. Resubmitted manuscript received. 你的稿件投稿人，会由三类人经手，1. 怎样才算“不同意”？. Remote Sensing. 6天了。. 4b. Note that the EiC typically makes the final decision on the manuscript. After this step, you're likely to receive a decision of acceptance with major/minor revisions (fingers Oct 27, 2023 · 大修返回后5天变成pending editor decision状态，但只能看到只能看到3个YES、3个CAN的那个审稿人的意见，他的意见是：本论文可以发表（6个yes），所以我的稿件应该是过了审稿人这一关了吧？请问等待编辑决定这个状态应该不会超过两周吧？ Jul 11, 2024 · MDPI旗下期刊，大修后 pending editor decision 11天. Mar 7, 2022 · 二审后Pending Editor Decision，但还有个大修意见. 19号大修意见 截止日期27号（两个审稿人，一个小修，提了22个问题，一个大修，8个问题）. Answer: This means that the Editor-in-Chief (EiC) has made a decision on the manuscript but still needs some information from you before they can communicate or proceed with that decision. But there are also a lot of areas that might be new and difficult to navigate. Nov 25, 2021 · 白丁. In case of a rejection, an article transfer will be considered. At this stage, the editor has to choose any one of the following outcomes for the paper: 1. 求问，一审大修提交之后直接pending editor decision 好焦虑啊，是约稿，一轮的时候编辑还推荐润色，目前看不到审稿人回复意见，直接pending editor decision 是什么情况啊，求指导，毕业太难了. When the handling editor is satisfied with the scientific aspects of the manuscript they’ll issue an editorial accept decision. yx cg iw sz rq op on bt xr my